Chapter · Teaching

Discipline Learned Through Pain

Choosing care while questioning the cost

Summary
I learned discipline through pain. As a father, I've chosen a gentler path—but I still wrestle with whether care alone is enough, or if avoiding harshness comes with its own cost.
By A Work in Progress
Jan 28, 2026

Scripture: Proverbs 22:15

Growing up, discipline was simple and absolute.

Bad behavior meant corporal punishment.
Not time-outs.
Not lost privileges.
Not conversations.

I didn't learn boundaries through explanation—I learned them through fear.

That kind of lesson stays with you.

What Pain Taught Me—and What It Didn't

As a child, punishment ended behavior quickly. That much is true.

But it didn't teach understanding.
It didn't build trust.
It didn't explain why something was wrong—only that it was dangerous to repeat.

What I learned was compliance, not character.

And that distinction matters now.

Doing the Opposite on Purpose

Many things learned in childhood follow us into adulthood. Others push us to react in the opposite direction.

For me, discipline became something I approached with hesitation instead of instinct.

There have been a few moments when I've spanked my kids—but those moments weigh on me. They don't feel corrective. They feel like failure.

It saddens me that my mind would ever even go there.

So instead, I lead with care.

TLC.
Conversation.
Guidance.
Patience.

Corporal punishment is rarely even a thought.

The Question That Won't Leave Me Alone

And yet—if I'm honest—I wonder.

Would my kids be better behaved if I used less care and more toughness?
Would stricter discipline create clearer boundaries?
Have I overcorrected?

These aren't questions rooted in anger. They're rooted in responsibility.

I don't want obedient children—I want capable ones.
But I also don't want permissive parenting disguised as kindness.

That balance is harder than it sounds.

Letting Life Teach What I Don't

Recently, a conversation stuck with me.

Sometimes, kids need to explore.
Sometimes, they need to get hurt—not dangerously, but naturally.
Not punished. Not rewarded. Just allowed to learn.

No lecture.
No consequence manufactured by authority.
Just reality saying, "That was a bad idea."

There's something powerful about that kind of lesson—one that doesn't come from me, but from experience itself.

Discipline Without Damage

"The rod of discipline..." — Proverbs 22:15

I don't read that verse as permission for harm.

I read it as a reminder that discipline matters—but the form it takes requires wisdom.

Discipline should guide, not scare.
Correct, not crush.
Shape, not scar.

I'm still learning what that looks like in practice.

What I'm Choosing—for Now

I choose care over fear.
I choose guidance over force.
I choose presence over power.

That doesn't mean I have it figured out. It means I'm paying attention.

Fatherhood has taught me that discipline isn't about controlling behavior—it's about shaping  person who can function when control is gone.

And while I still question myself, I know this much:
I refuse to pass down pain simply because it once passed through me.

Support this story

Buy Me Peace & Quiet

Writing these chapters takes stillness and a quiet place to think. If this chapter resonated with you, you can help create a little more peace and quiet — the kind that lets the next chapter exist.

Payments are processed by Stripe. See Terms and Privacy.

More on how support helps:

Tags

#discipline #fatherhood #parenting #self-reflection #values

Related Posts

Chapter · Vulnerable · Jan 18, 2026

The Fear I Carry About Their Future

One of the fears I rarely admit as a father is the fear that my children won't make it—that they'll struggle in a world that already feels u…

Chapter · Reflective · Jan 9, 2026

Breaking Familiar Patterns

Some patterns repeat because they're easy. Others repeat because they're familiar. This chapter reflects on the parts of my childhood I'm co…

Chapter · Reflective · Jan 11, 2026

When Presence Finally Outweighed Impressive

I didn't slow down because I had clarity—I slowed down because I wanted love. This chapter reflects on how chasing connection revealed that …

Chapter · Reflective · Jan 7, 2026

Responsibility Became Sacrifice

Before children, responsibility was about managing life. After children, it became about giving parts of myself away. This chapter reflects …

Chapter · Teaching · Dec 31, 2025

Discipline That Doesn't Break Connection

Discipline in fatherhood isn't about control—it's about care. This chapter reflects on learning how guidance, trust, and connection shape ch…

Chapter · Vulnerable · Dec 31, 2025

The Fear I Don't Say Out Loud

Fatherhood carries a quiet fear no one prepares you for—the fear of loss, of failing, of not being enough for the people you love most. This…